Comparing Chiropractic Spinal Manipulation and Nerve Root Injections for Lumbar Disc Herniations: A Comprehensive Analysis

Chiropractic Spinal Manipulation Vs. Nerve Root Injections for Lumbar Disc Herniations-Toronto downtown chiropractor

Are you considering chiropractic spinal manipulation for your disc herniation?

Have you been wondering if a nerve injection would help your lumbar disc herniation?

Instead of lower back surgery, a viable option could be nerve root injections or chiropractic spinal manipulation for your lumbar disc herniation.

In this article on Bodi Empowerment, I go over the pros and cons of chiropractic spinal manipulation vs. nerve injections.

Chiropractic spinal manipulation involves a chiropractor positioning you on your side and performing what is commonly known as “cracking your back.” However, I prefer to use the term “adjustment” to describe this procedure.


Nerve root injections involve the administration of a combination of a steroid (with anti-inflammatory properties) and lidocaine (a local anaesthetic commonly used in dental procedures) within a single syringe. The primary purpose of this procedure is twofold. Firstly, it serves as a diagnostic tool for identifying the source of pain. If the pain diminishes after the injection, it indicates that the nerve root may be the origin of the problem. In this process, lidocaine effectively numbs the pain, while the steroid works to reduce inflammation associated with the disc injury.

Nerve Root Injections Vs Chiropractic Spinal Manipulation

Chiropractic Spinal Manipulation Vs. Nerve Root Injections for Lumbar Disc Herniations-Toronto downtown chiropractor

If you have read Guide to Lower Back Surgery you know that I advocate conservative treatment such as chiropractic spinal manipulation, laser, rehabilitation exercises and acupuncture before doing surgery.

There is also another possibility that can help your lumbar disc herniation.  Nerve root injections.

In this particular research, they compared chiropractic spinal manipulation to nerve root injections for lumbar disc herniations. [1]

The researchers got 102 people with lumbar disc herniations that were confirmed by MRI. They divided the people into two groups. One group got chiropractic spinal manipulations while the other group got nerve root injections. The findings were very interesting.

Effectiveness of Chiropractic Spinal Manipulation Vs. Injections

The group getting chiropractic manipulation had 76.5% of the people improve while the group getting the nerve root injections improved by 62.7%. After a month the chiropractic spinal manipulation group had a 60% reduction in pain compared to the nerve root injection group, which had a 53% decrease in pain. Keep in mind the nerve root injection group seemed to be worse to start with compared to the spinal manipulation group.

It’s important to note that only one person in the chiropractic manipulation group got worse while three people in the nerve root injection group felt worse after the treatment.

The researchers in the study did a type of chiropractic manipulation for the lumbar spine called a pull or a push adjustment which I found aggravates disc herniations. However, only one patient gets worse with chiropractic manipulation.

I have found that lumbar roll a type of chiropractic manipulation is the most effective for disc herniations. Also, I often use acupuncture or other methods for the first few visits before using manipulation. I have crafted a different methodology to minimize aggravation of the lower back.

The problem with research is they try to find out the one thing that works compared to another. In reality, most chiropractors use many methods to get a patient better as no one method cures everything for everybody.

Chiropractic spinal manipulation for lumbar disc herniations is very safe compared to other types of treatment. Aggravation of the disc herniation is a rare occurrence that happens only in the most severely damaged lumbar discs.[2]

Costs

The costs of chiropractic spinal manipulation seem to be less than nerve root injections. From a financial point of view, chiropractic is better value. However, if you are covered for both types of treatments then you probably wouldn’t mind either one.  From my point of view though, I would rather not have a chemical inside my back if it can be done more naturally.

It took an average of 11 chiropractic spinal manipulation sessions in one month which is more cost-effective than nerve root injections. For those of you who have more severe cases of lumbar disc herniation, you will likely need more treatments.

For chiropractic, it would be more sessions, for the nerve root injections it would likely mean a second injection. Hopefully, your financial circumstances are not the drivers of your decision one way or another but the principle and the comfort level you have with the treatment will help decide which treatment is for you along with how effective the treatment is.

Longer-Term Follow-up

Research using other injections has shown people treated with betamethasone and bupivacaine elected not to have surgery at a 16-month follow-up whereas only 33% of those injected with bupivacaine alone avoided surgery.[4,5]

Keep in mind that both treatments were found to be effective at treating lumbar disc herniations. Essentially either treatment will do. I would always pick the chiropractic spinal manipulation, but I’m a little biased towards the natural ways.

How about you?

Tell us what you think in the comments below and like us on Facebook. This Toronto Downtown Chiropractor will answer all questions in the comments section.

  1. Peterson CK, Leeman S, Lechmann M, et al., Spinal Manipulation vs. Nerve Root Injection for MRI-Confirmed Lumbar Disc Herniation: Prospective Cohort, Journal of Manipulative & Physiological Therapeutics 2013; 36(4): 218-225.
  2. Oiphant D. Safety of spinal manipulation in the treatment of lumbar disc herniations: a systematic review and risk assessment. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2004; 27:197-210.
  3. Leininger B, Bronfort G, Evans R, Reiter T. Spinal manipulation or mobilization for radiculopathy: a systematic review. Phys Med Rehabil Clin N Am 2011; 22:105-25.
  4. Riew KD, Yin Y, Gilula L, et al. The effect of nerve-root injections on the need for operative treatment of lumbar radicular pain. A prospective, randomized, controlled, double-blind study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. Nov 2000;82-A(11):1589-93. [Medline].
  5. Riew KD, Park JB, Cho YS, et al. Nerve root blocks in the treatment of lumbar radicular pain. A minimum five-year follow-up. J Bone Joint Surg Am. Aug 2006;88(8):1722 [Medline].

Leave a Reply

  • If cervicogenic headaches are suspected, can a chiropractor inject the nerve block to diagnose it? Or does my son need to see a medical doctor for a diagnostic nerve block? He will definitely find a chiropractor to do the manipulations, but want to get a diagnosis. Already had a CT scan of his head and heart monitoring by the emergency room doctor and that was all “clean”. No-one has looked at his back or neck with an X-ray or anything. Doctors are just throwing migraine drugs at the headache that never goes away completely. Also he has neck pain, arm pain, dizziness, and scapular pain (how he ended up in emergency room) – massage seemed to help that a bit. All of the symptoms seem to be pointing towards cervicogenic headache, but we want to learn more. Thanks so much!

    • Post
      Author

      Thanks for your question Jean. A chiropractor doesn’t do injections but they can help with many types of headaches. I would go to a reputable chiropractor and see how you do. Remember this is an opinion and not a recommendation.

      Hope that helps your headache.

  • I had surgery for ap herniated disk I didn’t have pain in my back but in my hip down my leg to my ankle, after surgery I had no pain for 2 weeks, then it came back two-fold. I was set to go for the shots but it was taking to long to get an appointment so while waiting I went to a chiropractor. My pain is subsiding still in my groin area little in my lower leg and ankle. I’ve had 6 sessions with the chiropractor and my evaluation for the pain shots are now in 4 days. Do I get the shots or by going to the chiropractor will that relieve the pain now and will this last. My only other option per my Surgeon is for his to do surgery again. I do not want to go to the hospital it’ll be at least 5 days, my treatment in the hospital was horrible and will never again go willing. I can’t sit or stand for long periods or walk I am a 69 year old women but have worked out almost all of my adult life. What do you think should I get the shots and continue the chiropractic or thrust that my chiropractor will be enough?

    • Post
      Author

      Thanks for your question Carol. I think you should go to your chiropractor for a month. You can still go for the evaluation for the shots but delay the initial treatment until you give the chiropractor the chance to get better.

      If the chiropractor works great. If not get the shots? If not go for surgery?

    • That is a political answer that covers all phases. We are not fools, you covered yourself very well,I hope whoever is paying you for your expertise is aware of your unqualified answers.

      • Post
        Author

        John I have answered over 2000 comments to date helping as many people as I can. It’s too bad you look at life negatively and can’t see that I’ve given many thousands of hours of my time. If you think that’s negative you can do that. There are some people that simply give John. You must have had a tough life.

        I really hope that you can start to look at life in a more positive light. Good luck John.

        Please note that I will continue to give.